|
April 1997
Launching New Shows: A step-by-step guide
How to proceed from inspiration to the "Go" decision
By Rayna Skolnik
Of all the ways togrow your business, launching a new show ranks highest on both the riskscale and the reward scale. If the show doesn't meet expectations, you canlose money, reputation and even existing customers who might have decidedto participate in your new event. But if it flies, you get bragging rights-- and a whole lot more. "If you are successful, if your idea is onthat cutting edge, you are positioned for an incredible return on your investment,"says Jill Hilgenberg, Vice President and Show Director for PEMCO/ProfessionalExposition Management Co., Carol Stream, IL. Launching a show thus presentstwo simultaneous challenges. One is to try to come up with and develop agreat new idea -- a show that exhibitors and attendees really want and thatno one else is producing yet. At the same time, however, you need to beable to recognize the warnings that a particular idea won't work and bebrave enough to drop it.
The stages that show managers typically go through as they move a newidea from development to the go/no-go decision are not set in stone: Thesequence may vary, and the stages may overlap. But all the stages are needed,to a greater or lesser degree. For each stage, we've created a checklistof information you'll need to make your decision, as well as suggestionsfor where and how to get that information.
FINDING NEW IDEAS
Where to look
- Trade and consumer publications
- Television programs
- Your own shows
- Other trade or consumer shows
Tip: Do wide-ranging research, but stay focused on what you know."Look for markets that are not being served by other shows, and voidsor weaknesses in existing shows," suggests Lisa Julson, owner of JulsonConsulting and Event Management, Maple Ridge, British Columbia. "Readthe editorial in industry publications to find hot topics. And look at what'son TV - especially cable - if you do consumer shows." But whateveryou come up with, "Look for natural synergy with your current businesses."If you feel compelled to go into a completely different market, at leastbring in a consultant who knows that industry to work with you.
Tip: Follow other leaders. Be alert to new publications that comeout. "They've done the research for you," says Bob Harar, Chairmanof National Trade Productions Inc. (NTP), an Alexandria, VA-based show managementcompany. "They've identified a market, readers and advertisers. That'sa great sign. Now, find out if there's a show yet, or a major associationfor the industry."
When reading existing publications, keep an eye out for ads for new products.They can alert you to trends or emerging markets. If there's an industryconference without an accompanying trade show, this could be a possibilityfor a launch through a strategic partnership.
Brainpower to tap
Your industry peers
Your industry partners
Current and potential exhibitors
Current and potential attendees
Current and potential speakers
Your staff
Tip: To keep everyone's antennae up, make the search official."At least twice a year, we get everybody together and brainstorm,"says Harar, who aims to launch two new shows per year. "We put up 20or 30 ideas, just to keep the juices flowing. Maybe five appear more feasiblethan others and fit with what we're already doing." Those ideas arethen researched either by Project Managers Bill Rouse and Scott Clark, whofocus on new business development, or by another manager who is specificallyassigned to do the research. ASSESSING THE COMPETITION
What you need to know
- Who else is in the market?
- How do those shows compare with your idea?
What can you do that's different or better?
- If no one else is in the market--
why not?
How to find out
Check show directories, both in print and on the Internet, as well as industry associations to find out what other events serve the industry. If you're focusing on specific regions, check with convention and visitor bureaus.
- Read the exhibitor prospectuses and attendance-promotion brochures of related shows. Compare their positioning with your idea. Look for significant points of difference -- and be wary if you can't find any.
- Ask exhibitors and attendees: Are they totally satisfied with existing shows? What would they like to see changed? Is the scope of existing shows too broad or too narrow? Is any part of the market not adequately represented? Is the timing in sync with industry buying patterns? Are the right buyers targeted?
- Attend competitive events. What omissions or weaknesses can you spot?
- Analyze voids or failures. If no other show is taking your intended approach, find out why not. Is the idea truly too new for anyone else to have thought of it or had time to pursue it? Or is someone else researching it even as you are? If there was an event, and it failed: What went wrong?
Tip: Don't overvalue a void. "Entering the arena just becauseno one else is there is not a good idea -- it's premature," says Hilgenberg."You owe it to yourself to do baseline research."EVALUATING AN IDEA
What you need to know
- Do potential attendees and exhibitors want or need a show like the one you're proposing?
- Will they support the show?
- Will other industry players lend their support?
How to find out
- Identify the key players in the industry -- your potential exhibitors and attendees -- by checking trade publications, business newspapers such as the Wall Street Journal, the Internet and other shows that relate to the industry.
- Find out how potential exhibitors' products move through the distribution pipeline. Ask them: Are your needs being met by your direct sales force or sales outlets? By your advertising campaign? Are you meeting new customers? Are there any new customers?
- Ask potential exhibitors: Would such a show benefit your business? Will you serve on the Exhibitor Advisory Committee? Will you be a sponsor?
- Query current exhibitors and attendees as well. If your new idea is an offshoot of one of your existing shows, or relates to an industry in which you are now involved, current exhibitors and attendees can help you determine the need and focus the idea.
- Ask potential attendees: How do you buy your products? Is there a dedicated outside sales force that visits you regularly? Who makes the buying decision? Do you go to shows? Will this show make your job easier? Will it be financially beneficial for your company?
- Ask industry experts: Is the idea well focused? Does it appear viable? Will you serve on an advisory board, moderate a panel, or be a keynote speaker?
- Ask industry publications and associations: Will you be a co-sponsor?
Tip: Decide which is the cart and which is the horse. "Somepeople go right to the money source -- the exhibitors -- and, based on theirresponses, will do a show," says Harar. "I say: Start at the endand work your way back -- put the emphasis on the attendee side. If youhave attendees, the exhibitors will come."
How to conduct research
In person, one-on-one
In focus groups
With a telephone survey conducted by your company or an outside company
With a mailed survey conducted by your company or an outside company
Tip: Balance your research so it's both comprehensive and objective.Each of the research approaches listed above has its own pros and cons."There's no substitute for the ongoing research you do yourself,"says Julson. "But when you do your own research, you sometimes findthe answers you want. So it's important to have it validated independently."
Hilgenberg maintains that as much as 95 percent of the needed informationcan be obtained through internal research, which is both relatively quickand cost-effective. Nevertheless, "For a purely objective point ofview, outside research is the way to go," she says. A further benefit:"A research firm can often do a cross-analysis and spot a trend thatyou can't see."
Julson cautions that although "focus groups are great for fleshingout ideas, they produce a generalized response. To get specific responses,take that information to the public for a consumer show or to the industryfor a trade show, using a survey." She also observes that a mailedsurvey will in some ways be less representative of the total market thana phone survey. The reason: direct mail respondents are self-selected; theyrespond because they are already interested enough to complete the survey.On the telephone, however, people will indicate that they are ambivalent-- either by their words or by their tone of voice.
Phone research also doesn't have the constraints of a printed survey,with its check-boxes and multiple-choice questions. People talking on thephone are likely to digress and introduce new ideas. "You uncover nuggetsof information in a phone call that you'll never get in a survey,"says Hilgenberg.
ANALYZING THE MARKET POTENTIAL
What you need to know
- How big is the market now? How many suppliers and potential buyers?
- Who are the market leaders, the bellwether companies?
- Is the market growing or stagnant?
- Is it big enough to warrant a show?
- Is there a niche that warrants a show?
- Where should the show be?
- Would it be better to start with a conference program and eventually add a show?
How to find out
Review annual reports of the industry's major players: Is their business growing?
- Query the industry association: Is its membership growing?
- Look at the numbers of exhibitors and attendees at related shows, to estimate the potential participation at your event.
- Contact relevant government organizations.
Check the Internet, especially for statistical information. Review Publications' audit statements for reader demographics.
Tip: Narrow your Net. There's an enormous amount of informationon the Internet; the trick is finding what you want. Julson's solution:She looked up government listings in the phone book, then phoned agenciesthat looked promising and asked if they had a Web site. "After halfa dozen phone calls, I could go directly to the sites I wanted, insteadof just searching," she says.
To evaluate specific cities for a show, PEMCO's promotion manager checkedthe Census Bureau's Web site and found a manufacturing data pool that presentedthe number of manufacturing sites and number of employees by state and byZIP code. "If you know the SIC [Standard Industrial Classification]codes and can identify the geographic pockets, that is powerful information,"says Hilgenberg.
Tip: Coordinate your findings. For a consumer show, Julson pointsout that if you know what percent of the total population is involved ina particular hobby, how many people live in the region you're targeting,and what percent of the public usually attends shows, you can make an intelligentestimate of the potential attendance at your new event.
POSITIONING THE NEW IDEA
What you need to know
- What is your purpose/objective/mission?
- How is your idea different from those of existing shows?
- What changes or improvements can you offer?
How to find out
- Review all the information you've compiled.
- Refine and redefine the original positioning of your brand-new idea, based on what you have learned so far.
- Focus on your pluses, not the competition's minuses.
Tip: Don't start your research with a blank slate. "Whenwe talk to exhibitors and attendees, we have some basic positioning already,although the idea is pretty broad-brush," says Hilgenberg. "Wego to them on a need-fulfilment basis. Through the process, we might adda good deal of market information. As you come to the end of the process,the objectives and positioning will be much better defined."
Tip: Don't inadvertently boost the competition. "If you baseyour positioning just on the points of difference, you're wasting your moneyand helping the other guy," Julson warns. "Look at what your customerbenefits are and position yourself as a unique opportunity, but don't compareyourself to other shows."
CREATING A BUDGET
What you need to know
- What should you charge for booth space? Sponsorship opportunities?
- What should you charge for admission to the exhibit hall? The conference program?
- How much revenue will directory/program advertising generate?
- How much should you spend on marketing and promotions?
- What will it cost to produce the event?
- Who will provide financial support?
How to find out
- Check out the market. What are comparable shows charging for booth space, admission to the exhibits and the conference program? What's acceptable in the industry?
- Offer sponsorships and advertising to everyone who could benefit from the exposure -- key exhibitors, industry associations, publications, broadcast media -- and find out how much they typically spend.
- Use the budget from a comparable event that you have produced as a baseline, adjust for inflation, add startup costs and plan to spend more on promotions -- maybe.
- Look among industry associations and publications, as well as organizations with expertise complementary to your own, for prospective partners to share in the startup costs (and the eventual profits).
Tip: Decide if you want to conform to the norm or set yourselfapart. "There are two ways of thinking about pricing," Harar observes."Some people say that if there's competition, you should price a newshow lower. I believe in the Mercedes principle: If you're coming out witha quality product, charge what the top guns are charging. Attendees andexhibitors are used to these prices."
Tip: For sponsorships, especially, start the bidding high. Forone event, NTP initially considered charging $20,000 for sponsorships, butthen determined that $100,000 would be a perfectly fair price -- and soldfive. "You can always lower the price, if necessary, by offering dealsor specials such as Charter Exhibitor designation," says Harar.
Tip: There are several schools of thought when it comes to new-showpromotions. Some show managers say you must spend more in a show's firstyear or two because you are creating an identity; others say it's foolhardyto reduce spending after the first or second year because that change willtarnish the image.
Some suggest allotting 30 percent of projected revenues for first-yearpromotion; others say it should be 45 percent of the total budget. The formulacan also vary from one industry to another. Hilgenberg notes: "Oneindustry might demand glossier mailing pieces, or it might have a largerpress list." You'll need to strike the right balance between experience,conventional wisdom -- and gut feel.
PROJECTING ROI
What you need to know
- When will the event show a profit?
- Will the results be worth the effort?
- Is it a "Go"?
How to find out
- Project revenues from all sources -- exhibit sales, attendance, sponsorships, directory ads, etc. -- for at least three years.
- Project expenses for the same time period.
- Estimate when you can expect to exceed break-even and make a profit.
- Determine whether or not the results are acceptable to your company and make the "Go/No go" decision.
Tip: Every company's goals and requirements are different. Muchdepends on how large your company is and how long you can afford to waitbefore making money. "We set a goal we really believe we can reach,but we set our break-even about 20 percent below that," says Harar."We'd like to break even in the first year, and if we do -- great!But we expect to be showing a certain percentage of profit after three years."
Most show managers agree that it's unrealistic to expect to make a profitthe first year. "If it's truly a new concept, it takes time to buildawareness and an affinity for the event," says Hilgenberg. "Ifa show will lose $100,000 the first year, but in three years will make three-quartersof a million, it could be worth it. It's all in the projection -- and noneof us has a very good crystal ball."
Julson points out that smaller producers might be able to accept a smallerprofit margin because their overhead is lower. Nevertheless, she offersthis rough formula: "You should be able to pay the cost of the showthrough three to five years of profits."
How long will all this take?
You're exploring a long list of questions, considerations and concerns,but it shouldn't be a life's work. Julson suggests allowing three to sixmonths to research a totally new idea, but less for a clone of a show you'realready doing or in an industry that you already know well.
Harar finds that he and his staff can uncover the answers to 80 percentof their key questions in two to three months. "You could spend a yeartrying to come up with the other 20 percent of the answers, and meanwhileyou'll come up with new questions. So you'll never get 100 percent,"he says. And while you're doing all this research, of course, you couldbe attracting the attention of other show managers who might also thinkyour idea is a good one. Consequently, it's important to get your answers,and act on them, as quickly as possible.
Once you've decided to go with your idea, it will take another chunkof time to develop and implement a launch plan. Figure on 12 to 18 monthsfrom launch decision to show date; anything less than 12 months is pushingyour luck. That means that the "Go" decision must be made between12 and 18 months in advance of the optimum show date.
What if your "research" consists of sending out a prospectusto see who responds? "I've been there, too," says Julson. "Peopledo it all the time. But all the research stages are still necessary, evenif you do them in your head." Without basic research, it wouldn't bepossible to create a credible prospectus. But if you do take the quick-and-dirtyapproach, Julson adds, "Be prepared to make alterations along the way-- sometimes very close to the show."
But launching a show without doing adequate research goes against thegrain for Hilgenberg. "That's fine if you have bottomless pockets,or if you're looking for a hobby so you decide to produce trade shows. Butit's just not good business," she emphasizes. "We have a sayingat our company -- 'Never leap off the pier till you know what's in the water.'"
It's your idea and you're in love withit -- and that, say show managers, is one of the biggest challenges you face.It takes courage to admit that maybe the idea isn't so great after all andto acknowledge warning signs when you encounter them. Any of the followingfindings indicate that you might be on the wrong track:
- Industry saturation. Your research turns up several shows covering much the samemarkets that you have in mind -- or even one show that is established andhighly respected.
- Happy exhibitors or attendees. If participants are satisfied with the available shows andvoice no gripes, maybe they don't need your new show.
- Too few potential participants. When National Trade Productions Inc. (NTP), Alexandria, VA,was researching sites for a new regional show, ServerTech, debuting in Novemberin Washington, DC, Dallas was among the possibilities. "In Washington, there was a very targeted market of about 150,000 people we could readilyidentify," says Chairman Bob Harar. "But in Dallas, there were only about 30,000. If Dallas had been the only place we could have donethe show, we wouldn't have done it."
- Difficulty obtaining commitment. For a high-level banking industry event in Europe, NTP recruitedtop executives from major banks and companies of the caliber of IBM andUnisys to join the advisory board. "If we hadn't been able to get them,"says Harar, "that would have been a clear warning: Don't do it."
- Nebulous responses. Resistance to your idea is an obvious red flag. But fence-sitting is alsoa sign of trouble. That kind of reaction sometimes makes show managers think,"I know there's something here. We just haven't been talking to theright people. Maybe if we sent out a conference brochure we'd get a betterresponse." Or maybe you'd just waste time and money that should beinvested in an idea that would generate an enthusiastic response.
- Research that takes too long. "If you're approaching six months and still haven'tmade a decision, you're probably pushing the envelope too hard on viability,"says Jill Hilgenberg, Vice President and Show Director for PEMCO/ ProfessionalExposition Management Co., Carol Stream, IL. "You're scrambling toget support for the idea."
- Projected return that's too low. "If you're going to invest, say, half a million dollarsand will still be trying to make it back in 10 years, that's probably nota good debt to carry," Hilgenberg cautions.
|